Payroll Accuracy: The Dos and Don'ts

Originally published 8/21/2023; updated 3/18/2025.

Accurate payroll is more than just ensuring employees are paid correctly. It’s about compliance, cultivating employee trust, and protecting your business from costly mistakes. Payroll errors can lead to dissatisfaction, legal issues, and financial penalties—none of which your business can afford.

This guide will walk you through the key do’s and don’ts of payroll management. Whether you're a small business owner, an HR professional, or a payroll administrator, understanding these best practices will help safeguard your operations and build a thriving workplace.

Why Payroll Accuracy Matters

Payroll is the backbone of any business. It ensures employees are compensated fairly and keeps your company aligned with tax regulations and labor laws. Consider these critical impacts of payroll accuracy:

• Employee Satisfaction: One study revealed that 24% of employees would start searching for a new job after just one payroll mistake. Payroll accuracy is key to keeping morale high and turnover rates low.
• Compliance Risks: Missteps in payroll can result in penalties, audits, or even lawsuits, especially if you fail to meet tax filing deadlines or misclassify employees.

• Business Reputation: Payroll errors can tarnish your credibility. Both employees and external regulators expect processes to run smoothly. Mistakes can erode trust in your brand.

Now that we’ve established why accuracy is essential, here are the crucial do’s and don’ts for effective payroll management.

The Do’s of Payroll Accuracy

Do Regularly Audit Payroll Records

Payroll discrepancies can quickly turn into costly issues if left unchecked. Conduct periodic internal audits to identify errors in:

• Tax withholdings
• Employee classification
• Benefit deductions 

Proactively reviewing records ensures accuracy before a problem arises.

Do Keep Employee Information Up to Date

Accurate records are the foundation of a seamless payroll system. Verify and update employee details frequently, including:

• Addresses and bank account information
• Tax forms like W-4s
• Work hours, sick days, and vacation days

Encourage employees to notify HR immediately of any changes.

Do Use Automated Payroll Software

Manual processes are prone to human error. Automating your payroll system can save time and improve accuracy. Look for features like:

• Automatic tax calculations
• Integrated time-tracking
• Alerts for potential errors

Upgrade to modern tools for hassle-free processing.

Do Stay Compliant with Tax and Labor Laws

Tax regulations and labor laws often change. Stay informed about updates to:

• Overtime and minimum wage rates
• Federal, state, and local tax rules
• Employee classifications (e.g., exempt vs. non-exempt)

Non-compliance isn't just costly; it can damage your company's reputation.

Do Maintain Proper Payroll Documentation

Organized documentation is vital to retaining compliance and handling audits with ease. Always maintain:

• Pay stubs
• Tax filings
• Employee timesheets and employment agreements

These records are not only necessary for legal purposes but also invaluable for resolving disputes.

The Don’ts of Payroll Accuracy

Don’t Miss Payroll Deadlines

Missing payroll deadlines frustrates employees and can lead to fines. To avoid delays:

• Set automatic calendar reminders for payroll and tax deadlines
• Have a backup plan in case of system failures
• Build a buffer into your timelines to prevent last-minute stress

Don’t Misclassify Employees

Misclassifying workers is a common mistake with serious consequences. Understand the distinctions between:

• Employees and independent contractors
• Exempt and non-exempt status (for overtime eligibility)

Misclassifications can lead to financial penalties and legal scrutiny.

Don’t Forget to Double-Check Payroll Data

Even automated systems can have errors if the initial data is incorrect. Before processing:

• Verify hours worked and salaries
• Double-check benefits and tax contributions
• Ensure bonuses and commissions are calculated correctly 

A simple review can help prevent disputes.

Don’t Ignore Overtime and Holiday Pay Rules

Failing to compensate employees fairly for overtime or holiday hours can result in fines and lawsuits. To avoid this:

• Clearly define overtime rules in employee contracts
• Use payroll software to calculate additional pay accurately

Staying transparent about compensation builds trust and fosters loyalty.

Don’t Overlook Cybersecurity Measures

Payroll systems store sensitive employee data, making them prime targets for cyberattacks. Protect your system by using:

• Strong encryption protocols
• Multi-factor authentication
• Regular security audits 

This ensures your employees’ information remains secure.

Building a Reliable Payroll System

Payroll isn't just an operational necessity; it’s a strategic asset. When done correctly, it strengthens trust, ensures compliance, and saves your business money. Here’s how you can put these do's and don’ts into practice:

1. Invest in modern payroll solutions that automate calculations and flag potential discrepancies.

2. Partner with experts who can guide compliance with labor laws and tax regulations. 

3. Implement a systematic audit process to catch discrepancies early.

By focusing on accuracy, you're not just paying your employees—you’re building a happier, more secure workplace.

Partner With Experts to Avoid Payroll Pitfalls

Payroll can be complex, but you don’t have to handle it alone. Implementing the tips outlined above requires a blend of technology, organization, and expertise. Struggling with compliance, record-keeping, or payroll management? Consult with a professional payroll service to simplify your workload and ensure accuracy.

At The Payroll Company, we specialize in providing tools and services that streamline payroll and ensure compliance. From automated solutions to expert advice, we’re here to help grow your business with confidence.